Docker: Improve error output when bridge fails to start

Change-Id: I86d9d3972c483d21cd2ff64d3581b518e6b0a819
Reviewed-by: hjk <hjk@qt.io>

src/libs/gocmdbridge/client/bridgedfileaccess.cpp

@@ -68,22 +68,31 @@ expected_str<void> FileAccess::deployAndInit(
 
     qCDebug(faLog) << "Found dd on remote host:" << *whichDD;
 
-    const auto unameOs = run({remoteRootPath.withNewPath("uname"), {"-s"}});
+    const expected_str<QString> unameOs = run({remoteRootPath.withNewPath("uname"), {"-s"}});
-    if (!unameOs)
+    if (!unameOs) {
         return make_unexpected(
             QString("Could not determine OS on remote host: %1").arg(unameOs.error()));
+    }
+    Utils::expected_str<OsType> osType = osTypeFromString(unameOs.value());
+    if (!osType)
+        return make_unexpected(osType.error());
 
     qCDebug(faLog) << "Remote host OS:" << *unameOs;
 
-    const auto unameArch = run({remoteRootPath.withNewPath("uname"), {"-m"}});
+    const expected_str<QString> unameArch = run({remoteRootPath.withNewPath("uname"), {"-m"}});
-    if (!unameArch)
+    if (!unameArch) {
         return make_unexpected(
             QString("Could not determine architecture on remote host: %1").arg(unameArch.error()));
+    }
+
+    const Utils::expected_str<OsArch> osArch = osArchFromString(unameArch.value());
+    if (!osArch)
+        return make_unexpected(osArch.error());
 
     qCDebug(faLog) << "Remote host architecture:" << *unameArch;
 
-    const Utils::expected_str<Utils::FilePath> cmdBridgePath = Client::getCmdBridgePath(
+    const Utils::expected_str<Utils::FilePath> cmdBridgePath
-        osTypeFromString(unameOs.value()), osArchFromString(unameArch.value()), libExecPath);
+        = Client::getCmdBridgePath(*osType, *osArch, libExecPath);
 
     if (!cmdBridgePath) {
         return make_unexpected(

src/libs/gocmdbridge/client/cmdbridgeclient.cpp

@@ -259,15 +259,19 @@ expected_str<QFuture<Environment>> Client::start()
     d->jobs.writeLocked()->map.insert(-1, [envPromise](QVariantMap map) {
         envPromise->start();
         QString type = map.value("Type").toString();
-        QTC_CHECK(type == "environment");
         if (type == "environment") {
-            OsType osType = osTypeFromString(map.value("OsType").toString());
+            expected_str<OsType> osType = osTypeFromString(map.value("OsType").toString());
-            Environment env(map.value("Env").toStringList(), osType);
+            QTC_CHECK_EXPECTED(osType);
+            Environment env(map.value("Env").toStringList(), osType.value_or(OsTypeLinux));
             envPromise->addResult(env);
         } else if (type == "error") {
             QString err = map.value("Error", QString{}).toString();
             qCWarning(clientLog) << "Error: " << err;
             envPromise->setException(std::make_exception_ptr(std::runtime_error(err.toStdString())));
+        } else {
+            qCWarning(clientLog) << "Unknown initial response type: " << type;
+            envPromise->setException(
+                std::make_exception_ptr(std::runtime_error("Unknown response type")));
         }
 
         envPromise->finish();
@@ -284,9 +288,11 @@ expected_str<QFuture<Environment>> Client::start()
 
             connect(d->process, &Process::done, d->process, [this] {
                 if (d->process->resultData().m_exitCode != 0) {
-                    qCWarning(clientLog).noquote() << d->process->resultData().m_errorString;
+                    qCWarning(clientLog)
-                    qCWarning(clientLog).noquote() << d->process->readAllStandardError();
+                        << "Process exited with error code:" << d->process->resultData().m_exitCode
-                    qCWarning(clientLog).noquote() << d->process->readAllStandardOutput();
+                        << "Error:" << d->process->errorString()
+                        << "StandardError:" << d->process->readAllStandardError()
+                        << "StandardOutput:" << d->process->readAllStandardOutput();
                 }
 
                 auto j = d->jobs.writeLocked();

src/libs/utils/hostosinfo.cpp

@@ -31,7 +31,8 @@ bool HostOsInfo::m_useOverrideFileNameCaseSensitivity = false;
 
 OsArch HostOsInfo::hostArchitecture()
 {
-    static const OsArch arch = osArchFromString(QSysInfo::currentCpuArchitecture());
+    static const OsArch arch
+        = osArchFromString(QSysInfo::currentCpuArchitecture()).value_or(OsArchUnknown);
     return arch;
 }
 

src/libs/utils/osspecificaspects.h

@@ -3,6 +3,9 @@
 
 #pragma once
 
+#include "expected.h"
+
+#include <QDebug>
 #include <QString>
 
 #include <algorithm>
@@ -33,7 +36,7 @@ inline QString osTypeToString(OsType osType)
     }
 }
 
-inline OsType osTypeFromString(const QString &string)
+inline Utils::expected_str<OsType> osTypeFromString(const QString &string)
 {
     if (string.compare("windows", Qt::CaseInsensitive) == 0)
         return OsTypeWindows;
@@ -44,10 +47,11 @@ inline OsType osTypeFromString(const QString &string)
         return OsTypeMac;
     if (string.compare("other unix", Qt::CaseInsensitive) == 0)
         return OsTypeOtherUnix;
-    return OsTypeOther;
+
+    return Utils::make_unexpected(QString::fromLatin1("Unknown os type: %1").arg(string));
 }
 
-inline OsArch osArchFromString(const QString &architecture)
+inline Utils::expected_str<OsArch> osArchFromString(const QString &architecture)
 {
     if (architecture == QLatin1String("x86_64"))
         return OsArchAMD64;
@@ -59,7 +63,8 @@ inline OsArch osArchFromString(const QString &architecture)
         return OsArchArm;
     if (architecture == QLatin1String("arm64") || architecture == QLatin1String("aarch64"))
         return OsArchArm64;
-    return OsArchUnknown;
+
+    return Utils::make_unexpected(QString::fromLatin1("Unknown architecture: %1").arg(architecture));
 }
 
 namespace OsSpecificAspects {

src/plugins/docker/dockerdevice.cpp

@@ -313,7 +313,7 @@ public:
     QString repoAndTagEncoded() const { return deviceSettings->repoAndTagEncoded(); }
     QString dockerImageId() const { return deviceSettings->imageId(); }
 
-    QPair<Utils::OsType, Utils::OsArch> osTypeAndArch() const;
+    expected_str<QPair<Utils::OsType, Utils::OsArch>> osTypeAndArch() const;
 
     expected_str<Environment> environment();
 
@@ -332,6 +332,8 @@ public:
     void stopCurrentContainer();
     expected_str<void> fetchSystemEnviroment();
 
+    expected_str<FilePath> getCmdBridgePath() const;
+
     std::optional<FilePath> clangdExecutable() const
     {
         if (deviceSettings->clangdExecutable().isEmpty())
@@ -594,7 +596,22 @@ DockerDevice::DockerDevice(std::unique_ptr<DockerDeviceSettings> deviceSettings)
     : ProjectExplorer::IDevice(std::move(deviceSettings))
     , d(new DockerDevicePrivate(this))
 {
-    setFileAccess([this]() -> DeviceFileAccess * {
+    auto createBridgeFileAccess = [this]() -> expected_str<std::unique_ptr<DeviceFileAccess>> {
+        expected_str<FilePath> cmdBridgePath = d->getCmdBridgePath();
+
+        if (!cmdBridgePath)
+            return make_unexpected(cmdBridgePath.error());
+
+        auto fAccess = std::make_unique<DockerDeviceFileAccess>(d);
+        expected_str<void> initResult = fAccess->init(
+            rootPath().withNewPath("/tmp/_qtc_cmdbridge"));
+        if (!initResult)
+            return make_unexpected(initResult.error());
+
+        return fAccess;
+    };
+
+    setFileAccess([this, createBridgeFileAccess]() -> DeviceFileAccess * {
         if (DeviceFileAccess *fileAccess = d->m_fileAccess.readLocked()->get())
             return fileAccess;
 
@@ -603,15 +620,16 @@ DockerDevice::DockerDevice(std::unique_ptr<DockerDeviceSettings> deviceSettings)
         if (*fileAccess)
             return fileAccess->get();
 
-        auto fAccess = std::make_unique<DockerDeviceFileAccess>(d);
+        expected_str<std::unique_ptr<DeviceFileAccess>> fAccess = createBridgeFileAccess();
-        expected_str<void> initResult = fAccess->init(
+
-            rootPath().withNewPath("/tmp/_qtc_cmdbridge"));
+        if (fAccess) {
-        QTC_CHECK_EXPECTED(initResult);
+            *fileAccess = std::move(*fAccess);
-        if (initResult) {
-            *fileAccess = std::move(fAccess);
             return fileAccess->get();
         }
 
+        qCWarning(dockerDeviceLog) << "Failed to start CmdBridge:" << fAccess.error()
+                                   << ", falling back to slow direct access";
+
         *fileAccess = std::make_unique<DockerFallbackFileAccess>(rootPath());
         return fileAccess->get();
     });
@@ -835,13 +853,18 @@ expected_str<void> isValidMountInfo(const DockerDevicePrivate::MountPair &mi)
     return {};
 }
 
-QStringList DockerDevicePrivate::createMountArgs() const
+expected_str<FilePath> DockerDevicePrivate::getCmdBridgePath() const
 {
     auto osAndArch = osTypeAndArch();
+    if (!osAndArch)
+        return make_unexpected(osAndArch.error());
+    return CmdBridge::Client::getCmdBridgePath(
+        osAndArch->first, osAndArch->second, Core::ICore::libexecPath());
+};
 
-    const Utils::expected_str<Utils::FilePath> cmdBridgePath = CmdBridge::Client::getCmdBridgePath(
+QStringList DockerDevicePrivate::createMountArgs() const
-        osAndArch.first, osAndArch.second, Core::ICore::libexecPath());
+{
-
+    const Utils::expected_str<Utils::FilePath> cmdBridgePath = getCmdBridgePath();
     QTC_CHECK_EXPECTED(cmdBridgePath);
 
     QStringList cmds;
@@ -1325,7 +1348,7 @@ void DockerDeviceFactory::shutdownExistingDevices()
     }
 }
 
-QPair<Utils::OsType, Utils::OsArch> DockerDevicePrivate::osTypeAndArch() const
+expected_str<QPair<Utils::OsType, Utils::OsArch>> DockerDevicePrivate::osTypeAndArch() const
 {
     Process proc;
     proc.setCommand(
@@ -1333,13 +1356,21 @@ QPair<Utils::OsType, Utils::OsArch> DockerDevicePrivate::osTypeAndArch() const
          {"image", "inspect", repoAndTag(), "--format", "{{.Os}}\t{{.Architecture}}"}});
     proc.runBlocking();
     if (proc.result() != ProcessResult::FinishedWithSuccess)
-        return {Utils::OsType::OsTypeOther, Utils::OsArch::OsArchUnknown};
+        return make_unexpected(Tr::tr("Failed to inspect image: %1").arg(proc.allOutput()));
 
     const QString out = proc.cleanedStdOut().trimmed();
     const QStringList parts = out.split('\t');
     if (parts.size() != 2)
-        return {Utils::OsType::OsTypeOther, Utils::OsArch::OsArchUnknown};
+        return make_unexpected(Tr::tr("Could not parse image inspect output: %1").arg(out));
-    return {osTypeFromString(parts.at(0)), osArchFromString(parts.at(1))};
+
+    auto os = osTypeFromString(parts.at(0));
+    auto arch = osArchFromString(parts.at(1));
+    if (!os)
+        return make_unexpected(os.error());
+    if (!arch)
+        return make_unexpected(arch.error());
+
+    return qMakePair(os.value(), arch.value());
 }
 
 expected_str<Environment> DockerDevicePrivate::environment()

src/plugins/projectexplorer/devicesupport/idevice.cpp

@@ -500,7 +500,7 @@ void IDevice::fromMap(const Store &map)
     settings()->fromMap(map);
 
     d->id = Id::fromSetting(map.value(IdKey));
-    d->osType = osTypeFromString(map.value(ClientOsTypeKey, osTypeToString(OsTypeLinux)).toString());
+    d->osType = osTypeFromString(map.value(ClientOsTypeKey).toString()).value_or(OsTypeLinux);
     if (!d->id.isValid())
         d->id = newId();
     d->origin = static_cast<Origin>(map.value(OriginKey, ManuallyAdded).toInt());